Notes by: Adam Harper
Date: 18th August 2024
Writer(s): Mackenzie Crook
Pages: 35
Genre: Comedy
Score Card
| Plot | Characters | Tone | Writing | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Score | 3.5 | 4.5 | 4.5 | 4 |
Overall Score: 4
Plot Analysis
The first episode of Detectorists introduces its characters in a way that immediately reveals their passions and, perhaps, their methods of escaping life’s more mundane responsibilities. Instead of indulging in stereotypical ways to pass time like sports and beer, Andy and Lance find their joy in scouring fields for historical artefacts. This choice of hobby not only defines them but sets them apart from the typical “lads,” giving the audience a clear sense of who they are right from the start.
The pacing of the show is deliberately calm and steady, creating a reflective atmosphere that aligns with the characters’ leisurely pursuit. Despite this unhurried pace, the plot remains visually engaging and outwardly focused. While one could imagine a version of this story that dives into the internal musings of the characters, requiring the audience to interpret their thoughts, the show instead opts for more straightforward visual storytelling. Characters like Sophie, and eccentric farmer Lawrence Bishop serve as dynamic plot movers, propelling the narrative forward.
Being a serialised show, Detectorists doesn’t aim for complete resolution within a single episode. Instead, this first episode skilfully establishes the characters and sets up ongoing issues, such as Andy’s relationship with Becky and Lance’s lingering attachment to his ex, Maggie. The final act hints at a larger narrative arc involving Bishop and his land, setting the stage for future episodes. By this point, viewers have a solid understanding of the characters, and a clear sense of how the series might unfold.
Character Analysis
The tone of Detectorists relies heavily on its characters, who are crafted with enough quirks to elicit both smiles and laughter. The dialogue and interactions between characters are top-notch, with seemingly random conversations providing deep insights into Andy and Lance’s personalities. These two are similar enough to be believable friends but different enough to create both humorous and poignant moments. Their well-developed characters allow for concise action blocks that avoid unnecessary details, letting their personalities shine through in every scene.
While some characters are more understated, others, like Lawrence Bishop, are larger-than-life. This contrast works beautifully, as our flawed but grounded protagonists navigate a world filled with eccentric individuals. Bishop, in particular, serves as a perfect foil to Andy and Lance, highlighting their relatability and making their encounters with life’s oddballs all the more entertaining.
Tone Analysis
The understated nature of Detectorists made me curious about how this subtle tone would be conveyed in writing. Fortunately, the tone is captured well on the page, but the production elevates it further with soothing visuals and a calming rhythm in the shots and interactions. The show’s understated tone means that some plot points may not be immediately obvious, but this isn’t a drawback. Instead, viewers are drawn into a world that thrives on its seemingly uneventful nature. The humour doesn’t rely on elaborate setups or big set pieces; it emerges organically from the characters and their interactions.
While there’s little to critique about the tone, it’s worth noting that this is perhaps the script’s greatest achievement. The writing is excellent, but the actors and direction truly bring it to life, creating a sweet, funny package that’s hard to resist. If you’re looking to write something influenced by this script’s tone, pay close attention not just to what is written, but to what is left unsaid. The show often communicates more through its pauses and spaces than through overt action, making every line and interaction feel meaningful. Lance, in particular, is hilariously tragic—a character you can’t help but root for despite his flaws.
Writing Analysis
Detectorists is a dialogue-heavy show, and this is reflected in the script. This is understandable, as much of the show revolves around characters and their interactions rather than action. Even when the characters are engaged in some activity, it often serves as a device to facilitate conversation. The action blocks are succinct, devoid of unnecessary flourishes, which works well in letting the characters drive the story forward.
The dialogue is natural and relatable, with interactions that feel genuine and endearing. While the jokes aren’t punchy in the traditional sense, they come at a pace that suits the show’s laid-back tone perfectly. Cultural references are sprinkled throughout, adding an extra layer of humour, but it’s the character interactions that truly stand out.
As you’d expect, the writing is subtle, quintessentially British, and calm, making it a joy to read. It’s as impressive as one might hope, with the subtlety in the writing making it clear why this show is so beloved. The script captures the essence of the characters and the tone of the show brilliantly, making it a standout piece of work.
Summary / Feedback
In summary, this script is a triumph of tone and character. If there’s any critique to be made, it’s that the full brilliance of the script might not be immediately apparent without the production to back it up. However, even when considered as a standalone piece of work, the script impresses with its humour and the depth of its character interactions.
The show has a unique feel, set in an interesting, quintessentially British world. It’s a top-notch piece of work that succeeds in every area it aims to, making it a joy to analyse and appreciate.
As always, if you’re looking for feedback on your own script then feel free to reach out or check out my services page. See you next week!